Are we overemphasising self-improvement in leadership?

Summary

The constant pressure for self-improvement can be counterproductive, leading to dissatisfaction and neglecting the present moment. Instead of solely focusing on fixing our perceived flaws, we should embrace our unique strengths and celebrate our current achievements. True leadership often stems from self-acceptance and authenticity, rather than a relentless pursuit of an ever-elusive "better" version of ourselves. By finding a balance between growth and acceptance, we can unlock a more fulfilling and joyful life, both personally and professionally.

As a leadership coach I read a lot of leadership content online. Recently I’ve come across this pervasive message: always be growing, always be improving. Scroll through LinkedIn or any leadership blog, and you’ll find countless posts about how setbacks are merely opportunities for growth.

And many people proudly share their own methods of self-improvement (think getting up at 5 a.m.).

The prevalent narrative of “How every rejection is a stepping stone to success” is everywhere these days. From motivational speakers to social media influencers, we’re constantly bombarded with messages suggesting that setbacks are merely opportunities for growth and that every closed door is simply a redirection towards a better path.

While there’s undeniable truth in the value of learning from our mistakes and using challenges to fuel our determination, I’m concerned that this message is being oversimplified and, in doing so, potentially harming our well-being. Not every rejection holds a profound lesson, and constantly framing setbacks as positive can lead to unrealistic expectations and unnecessary self-blame.

The illusion of constant growth

The idea that we must constantly be evolving, always reaching for the next level, is appealing. It fuels our ambition and motivates us to strive for more. But it also creates an unrealistic expectation. It suggests that who we are in this moment is never enough, that there’s always a better version of ourselves waiting just around the corner.

This mindset can be damaging. It can lead to burnout, anxiety, and a constant feeling of inadequacy. It can also rob us of the joy of celebrating our present achievements and the satisfaction of simply being who we are.

The reality of setbacks

Let’s take job rejections as an example. While it’s true that we can sometimes learn valuable lessons from these experiences, it’s not always that simple.

Sometimes, the timing is off, the competition is fierce, or our resume simply doesn’t have the right keywords to get past an automated screening system.

In these cases, there’s often little to be learned in terms of self-improvement. You rarely receive feedback that is helpful.

The rejection might have nothing to do with our skills, qualifications, or potential. And yet, we’re often left feeling like we’ve failed, that we need to do more, be more, to succeed.

Embracing the present

I believe we need to shift our focus from constantly striving for a better future to appreciating the present moment. Instead of always chasing an elusive “next level,” we should be celebrating our unique strengths.

This doesn’t mean we should stop learning and growing altogether. Of course, personal and professional development is important. But it shouldn’t come at the expense of self-acceptance and contentment. We need to find a balance between striving for improvement and appreciating the journey.

In leadership, self-acceptance is a crucial but often overlooked quality. Leaders who are comfortable in their own skin, who embrace their strengths and weaknesses, are often more authentic, relatable, and effective.

They’re able to inspire trust and loyalty in their teams, not by pretending to be perfect, but by acknowledging their imperfections and demonstrating a willingness to learn and grow.

Coaching for self-acceptance

Leadership coaching can play a vital role in helping individuals cultivate self-acceptance. A good coach can help leaders identify their strengths, challenge their limiting beliefs, and develop the confidence to embrace their authentic selves. They can also provide support and guidance as leaders navigate the challenges of self-improvement, ensuring that it’s a healthy and sustainable process.

Conclusion

While the pursuit of growth is admirable, it’s important to remember that it’s not the only path to success and fullfillment. Self-acceptance, embracing our unique strengths, and appreciating the present moment are equally important. By finding a balance between these two aspects, we can lead more fulfilling lives, both personally and professionally.

Connect with me on LinkedIn.

afternoon setting in a dining room
Scroll to Top